27 Comments
User's avatar
Howard Salmon's avatar

Robert, thank you for taking the time to participate in this and for sharing so much of yourself in the process. Your answers carry the same sincerity and care that run through your music essays, and it’s a privilege to see the experiences and memories that shaped the voice so many of us admire. What comes through most strongly is how deeply rooted your love of music is in family, discovery, and connection—exactly the qualities that make this community feel alive. I’m grateful you stepped into this with such openness, and even more grateful you’re part of this space.

Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

Thanks, Howard, and thanks for the nudge to share a little bit about where my love of music came from.

Kevin Alexander's avatar

"Cannonball Adderley’s recording of ‘74 Miles Away’ from 1967"

I love this one too- thanks for getting it on my radar!

Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

You're welcome - very glad to have shared it with you. I remember very well hearing it on the radio for the first time, and being deeply shaken by it.

Ellen from Endwell's avatar

Carole King's Tapestry evokes comfort and a homey feel for me too.

Grew up with Johnny Mathis and second your sentiments about him.

Mark Nash's avatar

Loved this Robert, thanks for answering so many questions, I’m sure it was quite an undertaking. I’ve really enjoyed getting to know some of my favourite writers through this series.

P.S. I used to eat Oreos exactly the same way!! 🤣🤣

Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

Thanks, Mark! It's a fun series and grateful to those who got me to take part.

Andres's avatar

Thank you for your kind words, and thank you for answering my questions as well as the other writers' questions! I enjoyed getting to know a bit more about you. I so need to check those early Elvis recordings! I also loved what you said about Tapestry and the comfort feel of a home. Happy Sunday!

Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

My essays on Elvis are a good guide to the music - I could go on about it for ages. It all started there for me!

Harvey's avatar

Yes Robert, Projections, almost perfect and a masterpiece.

Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

I'll get to writing about it in the New Year.

John Nogowski's avatar

Good man, Robert. Rising tide…

Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

Exactly! The Substack community is amazing.

Lucian K. Truscott IV's avatar

Congratulations. I love your stuff.

Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

That means a lot to me! Keep fighting the good fight!!!!

William Poulos's avatar

Congrats on the nomination, and good luck! Loved reading your answers to these questions.

Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

Thanks, William, and thanks as well for all the support!

Charles Powell's avatar

"Seventy four miles away-that's out there!"

Thanks, Robert!

Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

Cannonball knew how to emcee!

wordsworthesq's avatar

Robert, these are really lovely answers and I appreciate the thought you put into them. I nodded in recognition at the McRea quote. Realized I need to get out that Blues Project album. And wanted to ask if you have heard the Mills Brothers delightful Xmas album. Thank you for sharing your background, your aspirations, and joys. I am looking forward to reading what you do next

Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

Thanks! Oh yes, well-acquainted with the Mills Brothers' Christmas album - wish I had a copy.

wordsworthesq's avatar

If I see it in my travels, I will grab it and send it along. It is superlative.

Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

Oh wow, thank you!

Peter Danakas's avatar

P.S. Robert, have you ever listened to Gene Pitney or Johnny Rivers? I think they're both quite underappreciated and definitely in the era/ style you like. It would be great to read whatever you wrote about them.

Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

I most certainly have. I wrote about Johnny Rivers earlier this year: https://www.listeningsessions.ca/p/johnny-rivers-sing-us-a-song. Gene Pitney is great too - he had a powerful set of pipes and an almost cinematic approach to singing (quite literally then thinking of 'The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance'). He'd be a good one to write about, for sure.

Peter Danakas's avatar

Congratulations! You definitely deserve it-- you do a great job of conveying your appreciation of underappreciated artists and their music. Keep up the great work! Have a great holiday season!

Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

Thanks, Peter - my best to you and your family for the holidays.