14 Comments
User's avatar
Alternative Lives R Available's avatar

I first heard Safe as Milk in my mid teens, and I still play it today more than 50 years later. My favourite tracks change, but each feels novel and creative even today, at least to me.

I liked Beefheart's work with Zappa too - extraordinary voice and personality, but much of Beefheart's later work I found too 'out there' for me. I think I may be too sane!

Expand full comment
Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

Very little I have heard of Beefheart after 'Safe as Milk' moves me in any way, making what he achieved in that first album especially extraordinary. It's, in a way, accessible avant-garde music.

Expand full comment
Robert Kovar's avatar

I found my way into TMR by listening repeatedly while doing household chores. When it clicks, you may find, as I did, that it’s full of hooks. I had young kids when I got it, and to this day, they’ll spontaneously call out, “it’s the blimp, Frank!” 🙂

Expand full comment
Gerald Brennan's avatar

Everyone just needs to let down their guard and get into Trout Mask Replica. I mean it.

Expand full comment
Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

I have to pull it out soon and give it a good re-listen.

Expand full comment
Robert Kovar's avatar

My daughter actually texted me after I posted this that she saw a blimp today and had to tell her boyfriend about “The Blimp”!

Expand full comment
wordsworthesq's avatar

Diana Marcovitz is new to me, so I really appreciate the introduction.--the strength of your writing made me want to listen. The thing I noticed while listening to her is how she reminded me of Tom Lehrer in some ways, which means that if I find her albums in the wild, I'll be adding them to the collection.

Expand full comment
PTBirnam's avatar

“Trout Mask Replica, an album so intimidating in its sprawl and uncompromising in its radical rejection of anything resembling normalcy that I’ve only ever dared play it twice.”

Absolutely! I had to own TMR after hearing several of my favorite artists cite its influence. But like you, I find it challenging to listen to.

A glimpse into the mind of The Captain’s mind:

(Fast forward to 2 min 0 seconds for the Captain’s interview)

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=MGGWMVGBYhQ

“Safe As Milk”!

I’m so delighted to see attention paid to one of my favorite recordings. While I seldom listen to the other tracks, to me #6, 7, 8 & 9 are precious jewels.

Thank you, Robert, for your post!

Expand full comment
Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

You're very welcome - thanks for the kind words and the YouTube link.

Expand full comment
Lucian K. Truscott IV's avatar

I was there in '74 in NYC living at 124 W Houston. It was the best year of them all, and the rest of the 70's were fucking great.

Expand full comment
Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

I can only imagine the rush of being there, though I think I feel just the slightest hint of it every time I visit New York.

Expand full comment
Alan Zweig's avatar

David Stoughton “Transformer”. If you come across it. It fits right in.

Expand full comment
Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

Oh yes - it goes way out there. I've only ever streamed it but would grab a copy if I ever came across it crate digging.

Expand full comment
Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

Best of luck - I was glad I stumbled on her album (she made one more which I have never seen and is not available for streaming). Lehrer is someone I know but am no way familiar with - I recall Randy Newman speaking appreciatively of him.

Expand full comment