4 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
NickS (WA)'s avatar

A nice article; thorough and fair. I appreciate the lengthy discussion of Linda Rondstadt; someone I respect but have never been particularly drawn to.

I will note, in passing, that I was just looking into a Judee Sill song ( https://substack.com/@earnestnessisunderrated/note/c-49333672 ) and J.D. Souther does not come across well in that store.

Expand full comment
Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

Thanks so much. I forgot that 'Jesus Was a Cross Maker' was about Souther.

I am a huge Linda Ronstadt fan - I got seriously into her music about 11 years ago and her music helped me get through a tough time. One day, I shall write an essay exclusively about her.

Expand full comment
NickS (WA)'s avatar

I understand, and that prompts an interesting through. David Bowie's _Ziggy Stardust_ album helped me get through a tough time, and I think there was something about the combination of deep emotion and also artificiality that helped me process my emotions while keeping them at a little bit of distance.

Normally I'm a fan of music that feels more emotionally direct, but in that case it felt like a little bit of indirection was helpful (again, not that it wasn't emotion, but that the performance was displaying emotion that had been processed, rather than raw), and, for me, I have a similar reaction to Linda Rondstadt.

As a side note, I did really enjoy the documentary about her a few years ago.

Expand full comment
Robert C. Gilbert's avatar

Agree about the documentary. It's interesting to what music helps someone out during tough times so appreciate you sharing about Bowie's Ziggy Stardust album.

Expand full comment